Flutter Crumb Bakery Order Now

Limited weekly menu

Cookies, boxes, and assorted bundles.

Browse current offerings below. Online orders are pickup-only and must be paid before they are confirmed.

Classic Cookies

Classic Cookies

Simple, familiar favorites available by the half dozen, dozen, or two dozen.

Classic Cookies

Chocolate Chip

Classic soft-baked chocolate chip cookies.

Half Dozen $12.00
Dozen $22.00
2 Dozen $40.00

Classic Cookies

Birthday Sprinkle

Soft birthday sprinkle cookies with a sweet celebration-style finish.

Half Dozen $12.00
Dozen $22.00
2 Dozen $40.00

Classic Cookies

Double Chocolate

Rich chocolate cookies with extra chocolate throughout.

Half Dozen $12.00
Dozen $22.00
2 Dozen $40.00

Deluxe Cookies

Deluxe Cookies

Richer specialty flavors with upgraded toppings and finishes.

Deluxe Cookies

Turtle Sundae

A deluxe cookie with turtle sundae-inspired flavor.

Half Dozen $15.00
Dozen $28.00
2 Dozen $50.00

Available adjustments:

  • No Caramel Drizzle

Deluxe Cookies

S’mores Chocolate Chip

Chocolate chip cookies with a s’mores-inspired twist.

Half Dozen $15.00
Dozen $28.00
2 Dozen $50.00

Stuffed Cookies

Stuffed Cookies

Premium filled cookies with richer centers and optional topping adjustments.

Stuffed Cookies

Biscoff Cookie Butter

Stuffed cookie filled with Biscoff cookie butter.

4-Pack $18.00
Half Dozen $28.00
Dozen $55.00

Available adjustments:

  • No Cookie Butter Drizzle
  • No Biscoff Cookie Topper

Stuffed Cookies

Oreo Cookies and Cream

Stuffed cookies and cream cookie with a sweet topping finish.

4-Pack $18.00
Half Dozen $28.00
Dozen $55.00

Available adjustments:

  • No Topper

Assorted boxes

Mix flavors without making fulfillment messy.

Assorted boxes are structured by category so customers get variety while Faith still receives a clear bake summary.

Assorted Box

Half Dozen Assorted Sampler Box

$25.00

Includes 2 Classic, 2 Deluxe, and 2 Stuffed cookies.

Classic Cookies 2 cookies

Choose up to 2 flavors

Deluxe Cookies 2 cookies

Choose up to 2 flavors

Stuffed Cookies 2 cookies

Choose up to 2 flavors

Total: 6 cookies

Assorted Box

Full Dozen Assorted Box

$40.00

Includes 4 Classic, 4 Deluxe, and 4 Stuffed cookies.

Classic Cookies 4 cookies

Choose up to 2 flavors

Deluxe Cookies 4 cookies

Choose up to 2 flavors

Stuffed Cookies 4 cookies

Choose up to 2 flavors

Total: 12 cookies

Assorted Box

2 Dozen Party Pack

$72.00

Includes 8 Classic, 8 Deluxe, and 8 Stuffed cookies.

Classic Cookies 8 cookies

Choose up to 2 flavors

Deluxe Cookies 8 cookies

Choose up to 2 flavors

Stuffed Cookies 8 cookies

Choose up to 2 flavors

Total: 24 cookies

Ready to order?

Choose your box, select pickup, and pay before confirmation.

Start an Order